Share on bsky
I wrote the first draft of it in my head while brushing my teeth on a Tuesday.
Not literally wrote it down. Just started composing, the way I do, foam at the corner of my mouth, staring at nothing in the mirror, arranging and rearranging the words I was going to say to my friend the next time I saw her. I owe you an apology. I’ve been thinking about Saturday, and I said something that I don’t think landed the way I meant it, and I want to own that.
I rinsed. Spit. Kept going.
By Wednesday the apology had grown a second paragraph.
I don’t even remember, now, what set it off. Something small—a comment I’d made at dinner, half a joke, the kind of thing that leaves your mouth before you’ve finished deciding if it’s funny. My friend had gone quiet for a second afterward. Maybe two seconds. Probably nothing. Probably she was just chewing.
But I have a mind that treats two seconds of silence the way other people treat a house fire.
There’s a particular flavor of dread that comes from believing you’ve hurt someone you love. It sits low in the stomach, a little to the left, and it doesn’t announce itself as dread exactly—it dresses up as diligence. As responsibility. As being a good friend who takes accountability. I have spent so much of my life mistaking this feeling for virtue that I stopped being able to tell the difference between genuine remorse and a nervous system that simply prefers catastrophe to uncertainty.
By Thursday, I had rehearsed the apology in the shower, in the car, once in the cereal aisle of the grocery store, standing in front of the granola with my cart at an angle, mouthing the word unintentionally to myself like a woman rehearsing a court testimony.
I want to tell you I was gentle with myself during this. I wasn’t. I was gathering evidence. I replayed the exact tone of my own voice at that dinner table, trying to hear it the way she might have heard it, which is a task about as reliable as trying to read a book underwater.
I think overthinking is often just guilt that hasn’t found a body to live in yet, so it moves into your whole day instead. It rearranges the furniture. It takes over the kitchen table and the shower and the cereal aisle. It becomes the room you can’t stop walking back into.
I’ve read the theories. The ones about hypervigilance, about nervous systems trained young to scan a room for the first sign of someone’s disappointment, about how some of us learned before we could talk that being loved was conditional on being easy to love in a specific, narrow, unchanging way. I know the theories. Knowing them did not stop me from standing in a grocery store on a Thursday whispering the word unintentionally to a shelf of granola.
Knowledge and nervous system don’t always share a bloodstream.
Friday, I texted her. Not the apology—not yet. Just: hey, are we still on for coffee tomorrow?
She wrote back in about four minutes. Yes!! can’t wait, it’s been forever.
Two exclamation points. I read them three times, the way you’d reread a lab result, looking for something buried beneath the plain meaning of the words. I could not find anything buried. There was nothing buried. It just said what it said.
I sat with my phone in my hand for a long minute anyway, in that particular late-afternoon light that comes through my kitchen window around five, gold and a little dusty-looking, the kind of light that makes even ordinary moments feel like they’re being filmed. I remember that light specifically. I don’t remember what I made for dinner that night, or what we talked about at coffee two days before that, but I remember the light on my phone screen and the two exclamation points and the strange, sinking realization that I might have spent four days in a burning building that was never actually on fire.
We met for coffee on Saturday. She was already there when I arrived, had ordered for both of us out of habit, was mid-story about her sister’s new dog before I’d even sat down. I kept waiting for an opening. A pause long enough to say I need to apologize for something. The pause never quite arrived, or maybe I just kept talking through it, the way you keep circling a parking lot looking for a spot that was never going to appear.
Eventually, almost as an afterthought, I said, “Hey—I hope what I said at dinner the other night didn’t come across wrong. The joke about your work thing.”
She looked at me with genuine, unguarded confusion. Not the performed kind. The real kind. “What joke?”
I told her. She laughed—actually laughed, a real one—and said, “Oh my God, no, I don’t even remember that. I think I was just tired that night.”
That was it. The whole thing. Four days, several rehearsals, one grocery store, one dramatic patch of late-afternoon light, dissolved into six words and a laugh over oat milk lattes.
I used to think the lesson here was obvious. Something like stop overthinking, most of what you worry about never happens. I’ve said that sentence to other people. I’ve probably written it somewhere before, believing it while I typed it.
But sitting there across from my friend, watching her already moving on to the next story before I’d even fully exhaled, I didn’t feel lessoned. I felt something closer to grief. Grief for the four days. Grief for the version of me standing in the cereal aisle, so certain she’d broken something, so willing to carry a harm that had never actually landed anywhere except inside her own body.
Where does that go? I wonder. Four days of a feeling with nowhere real to put it. It doesn’t just evaporate because the crisis turns out to be imaginary. It has to go somewhere. I think mine went into my shoulders, which were up around my ears for most of that week without my noticing. I think some of it went into a headache I blamed on the weather.
I don’t have a tidy ending for this. I wish I did. I wish I could tell you that after my friend laughed it off, something permanently recalibrated in me, that I never again rehearsed an apology I didn’t need to give.
That’s not true. I did it again three weeks later, over something even smaller, a comment to my mother that probably meant nothing to her and meant everything to me for the better part of a Sunday.
Maybe the truest thing I can say is that I noticed it a little faster the second time. Noticed the shoulders creeping up. Noticed the granola-aisle energy building before I was standing in an actual aisle. I didn’t stop it. I just recognized it a little sooner, the way you recognize a song halfway through the first note because you’ve heard it so many times before.
I think that might be what healing actually looks like sometimes. Not the absence of the pattern. Just recognizing it a beat earlier than you did the last time, standing there in your own kitchen, watching the light change, waiting to see what you’ll do with the extra half-second you’ve bought yourself.
~
Read 1 comment and reply